ManyPets vs. Lemonade

ManyPets and Lemonade: A paw-by-paw comparison

From payouts to coverage, learn how ManyPets stacks up against Lemonade pet insurance.

  • No annual payout limits
  • No hidden fees
  • Dental accidents and illnesses covered*
4.6 out of 5
4.6 out of five star rating on Trustpilot
4.6 | NaN
Read more reviews at trustpilot
Dog with ball in mouth

Why choose ManyPets?

Your choice of pet insurance company could impact not just your bank account but also your pet's health.

ManyPets offers nose-to-tail* coverage at competitive prices, with no hidden fees or annual payout limits. Here's how we compare to Lemonade.

How does ManyPets compare to Lemonade?

Features ManyPets Lemonade
No annual limit 🚫
Can quote any breed up to 14 years of age 🚫
All plans cover sick visit exam fee 🚫
All plans cover dental illness 🚫
Diagnostic testing
Vet specialists & ER visits
Cancer treatment
Customer service agents (actual humans!) 🚫

Comparisons are based on information manually taken from each competitor's website in on November 30, 2023. These are subject to change at any time.

Forbes Advisor 2023. America's best pet insurance company. ManyPets was awarded 5 stars

Forbes' #1 Pet Insurance Company for 2023

Choosing pet insurance: key considerations

The right pet insurance company can protect your finances and your pet. Here's what to look for.
Basil conditions covered

Nose-to-tail coverage*

ManyPets offers wide-ranging coverage for accidents and illnesses.

Basil Claims Paid

No payout limits

ManyPets has no annual or lifetime limits on payouts for eligible claims.


No extra fees

ManyPets includes no added or hidden fees


Hereditary conditions

ManyPets covers conditions common to your breed unless they're pre-existing.

A paw holding a globe

Dental coverage

ManyPets covers dental illnesses in addition to dental accidents.

Basil Painless

Competitive pricing

Independent industry observers* find that ManyPets offers competitive prices relative to its peers.

5-star pet insurance customer reviews from Trustpilot

From substantial reimbursements to outstanding support, hear from our customers about life in the ManyPets pack.
A pile of puppies climbing on each other in a pyramid

Find the best insurance for all your woofs and meows

ManyPets offers coverage for dogs and cats, including puppies and kittens, adult dogs and cats, and senior dogs and cats.



Unlike some other providers, ManyPets policies may cover claims related to accident or illness exams and periodontal disease, and we don’t place annual limits on payouts for approved claims, even as your pet gets older.

*ManyPets analyzes every claim on its own merits, subject to the terms and conditions of your policy. Exclusions apply, including those for pre-existing conditions. Only claims unrelated to an excluded treatment or condition are eligible for coverage.