Our tailmates know us so well, and they're in sync with our body language, emotions and routines.
Dogs are so closely aligned with us that if anything changes - even emotions - your dog will pick up on it.
But can dogs sense sadness in us? They certainly can!
So, how does this happen, and can all dogs sense it? Let’s explore this further.
Can dogs sense sadness in humans? What the research shows
:quality(75))
Various studies investigate how dogs react to different human emotions.
A recent 2024 paper by Bräuer et al. described the following:
"We found that dogs behaved differently depending on the owner's emotional state: they gazed and jumped less at owners when they were sad, and their compliance with the 'sit' command was also diminished. When owners were happy, dogs performed better in the trained task."
The paper explored the reasons why this ability to tune into our emotions exists. Emotional intelligence is an adaptation that helps dogs determine whether something is safe and likely to be beneficial (like food!) or a potential threat.
This was an idea demonstrated by earlier work by Merola et al. published in 2012. This behaviour is known as social referencing, which is described by the authors as follows:
"Social referencing is a process whereby individuals use another's emotional cue towards a novel object/event to guide their own future behaviour towards it."
In other words, dogs may look at how we react to something, whether positively or negatively, to determine how they should also respond.
This means that dogs can sense sadness in people and it may affect the way they behave.
What small studies can't tell us
While they can detect mood changes, it's proposed that dogs can’t demonstrate sympathy or empathy.
For dogs to be empathetic, they must understand the situation and be able to react appropriately, such as thinking of practical ways to help. This means their reactions are due to information gathering, rather than true empathy.
However, the 2024 paper by Bräuer et al. concluded with the following:
"While dogs may not be empathic, their tendency to constantly monitor humans, their ability to perceive when something is wrong with the owner and their motivation to help can be highly valuable for humans and should be further investigated."
This indicates that more research may be carried out in this field. It’s also unclear whether studies carried out in laboratory settings can truly represent real-world scenarios, and it’s likely more detail is needed on breed variations.
How dogs notice sadness
:quality(75))
Dogs are creatures of habit and rely on routine. They also constantly use subtle social cues from you to make sense of what's going on in the world around them.
Your dog may notice the following when you're upset:
A difference in your behaviour, including crying, nose blowing, or spending more time cuddled up on the sofa.
A difference in your facial expressions.
Changes in your body language, like your posture and the way you are moving around the house.
Changes in your tone of voice.
Disruption to their normal routine, such as delayed walk times or less play time.
Do dogs smell sadness, then?
It's certainly possible that dogs can smell changes in our biochemistry, with subtle shifts in hormones and body odour often occurring due to sadness or stress.
But because sadness is usually accompanied by other much more obvious signals like changes in voice tone, body language, and behaviour, we can't be certain which element it is that your dog is picking up on.
How do most dogs respond when their pet parent is sad?
:quality(75))
Emotional mirroring: Dogs can mirror our stress or anxiety. Your emotions can make some sensitive pets feel stressed and worried themselves. This can cause them to become more withdrawn, inactive, or tense than normal. Some pets may distance themselves from you to avoid potential threats.
No reaction at all: Some dogs may not show any outward responses to your sadness at all. This is driven by your pet's breed, past experiences, personality, and bond with you, as well as their inability to help with the situation.
Quieter demeanour: Some dogs may be calmer and quieter in response to your sadness, with less exuberant body language than usual.
Showing signs of comfort: Resting their head on you, nudging you with their nose, or licking you may all be interpreted as offering you some comfort or support.
Staying physically close to you: Your dog may lean against you, sit nearby, or follow you around the house.
Do dogs typically react differently to non-owners?
The evidence behind this is mixed. Dogs are constantly problem-solving and gathering information, so it’s proven that they can recognise emotional expressions in strangers as well as owners.
But their reaction to the situation may depend on the type of emotion being shown by the non-owner, the dog’s attachment to that person, and the dog’s own emotional state.
Can dogs sense depression and anxiety without knowing the cause?
:quality(75))
As we have already explored, dogs are very good at detecting subtle signals. This means that they may be able to detect differences in mood and mental health, even if they don’t understand the underlying cause.
Emotional support animals (ESAs) are known to provide a calming presence and companionship, which can be helpful for pet parents struggling with conditions like anxiety. Unlike service animals, ESAs don’t usually have any specialised training or detection abilities; they just provide comfort and routine for owners or handlers.
If you suspect you have symptoms of anxiety or depression, then please speak to your GP for support.
Can being sad or crying make your dog stressed?
Yes, in some cases, dogs may become stressed by your emotional state. This is more typical during periods of chronic stress or sadness in the house, especially when their daily routine and interactions with you have dramatically changed.
But you shouldn't feel guilty about the way you process your feelings. Most dogs will be absolutely fine, provided they are still getting their needs met.
If you are struggling, then it is worth speaking to friends and family, or a dog walker, to help you care for your pet during particularly emotional times.
Why some dogs barely react at all
:quality(75))
Just like people, different dogs are better at picking up on emotions than others. This can be due to multiple factors, but breed and personality play a big part.
Typically, breeds with high levels of emotional intelligence (EI) react the most. Breeds that consistently rank as having high levels of EI include:
Border Collies
Cavalier King Charles Spaniels
German Shepherds
Golden Retrievers
Labrador Retrievers
The ways in which dogs will then show their emotional support often vary too. It can be obvious, nuzzling and leaning up against you, or more subtle, such as sitting in the same room or casually observing you.
Some dogs feel they are unable to help in any practical way and therefore keep their distance altogether.
FAQs
Does my dog’s lack of reaction mean they don’t care?
While we can't know what your dog is thinking for sure, we do know that all dogs react to emotional cues differently. Some are better than others at identifying that their pet parent is upset in the first place. But how they handle the situation will often be different too.
Remember that no matter how your dog responds, it is likely they are demonstrating social referencing rather than true empathy, as the evidence is lacking that dogs can truly understand human emotions.
Do dogs know when you’re crying?
Yes, a dog will certainly know when you are crying, as your behaviour, body language, and perhaps even smell, will change.
Dogs are tuned in to these cues so that they can respond accordingly, which is an important social skill to help them avoid potential threats. How different dogs respond to tears will vary, though.
Can dogs sense sadness in other dogs?
Dogs will use body language, behaviour, and vocalisation cues to work out how other dogs are feeling. As intelligent and sociable animals, recognising the emotions of other members of their species is an important skill.
:quality(75))
:format(jpeg):quality(75))
:quality(75))
:quality(75))
:quality(75))
:quality(75))
:quality(75))
:quality(75))
:quality(75))